In five minutes: what is dark matter?
Dark matter is the name for whatever supplies the extra gravity we measure in galaxies and galaxy clusters but cannot see. It does not shine, absorb or reflect light, so telescopes miss it, yet its pull shapes the universe.
Astronomers estimate that it makes up about 85% of all matter, and roughly 27% of everything in the universe. Ordinary matter, the stuff of stars, planets and people, is only about 5%.
The remaining 68% or so is dark energy, a separate puzzle that makes the expansion of space speed up. The two names sound alike, but they describe different things.
The argument fits in two sentences. The visible mass in a galaxy is not enough to explain how it moves, so either there is unseen mass or gravity behaves differently than we think.
Almost all the evidence points to unseen mass. The twist is that, after decades of searching, no experiment has confirmed what that mass is made of.
That gap between what we can measure and what we can explain is exactly where writers like to work. If you want the wider story of how the genre grew, start with our guide to the history of science fiction.
How we found something we cannot see
In 1933 the Swiss astronomer Fritz Zwicky studied the Coma Cluster, a huge group of galaxies. The galaxies moved so fast that the cluster should have flown apart unless it held far more mass than its light suggested.
Zwicky called the missing material dunkle Materie, German for dark matter.
Most astronomers did not take the idea very seriously for decades. The turning point came around 1970, when Vera Rubin and Kent Ford measured how fast stars and gas orbit in the Andromeda galaxy.
In our solar system, planets far from the Sun move more slowly than planets close to it. Neptune crawls compared with Mercury.
In Andromeda, and later in many other spiral galaxies, the outer stars moved about as fast as the inner ones. With only the visible mass, those outer stars should have been flung away.
A huge invisible halo around each galaxy makes the motion work. Rubin kept collecting such measurements through the 1970s and 1980s, and by then the pattern was hard to ignore.
Three more clues that point the same way
Gravitational lensing
Einstein's general relativity says mass bends the path of light. When astronomers look at distant galaxies through a cluster, the images are stretched and bent.
The amount of bending shows how much mass the cluster holds. It is consistently several times more than the stars and gas can account for.
The cosmic microwave background
The cosmic microwave background is the faint afterglow of the early universe. Its tiny temperature ripples were mapped in detail by the European Space Agency's Planck satellite.
The pattern of those ripples fits a universe with about 27% dark matter and 5% ordinary matter. It does not fit one with ordinary matter alone.
The Bullet Cluster
In 2006 a team using the Chandra X-ray telescope and lensing maps studied two galaxy clusters that had collided. Most of the ordinary matter in a cluster is hot gas, and in the crash the gas was slowed down and left in the middle.
The mass revealed by lensing, however, passed straight through and ended up ahead of the gas. That is just what you would expect if most of the mass is something that barely interacts with itself or with gas.
The real science: what is known and what is guessed
Here is what is established. Something with gravity is there, it is found in galaxies and clusters, and several independent methods agree on how much.
It is also not made of ordinary atoms. The amounts of hydrogen and helium made in the Big Bang would come out wrong if it were.
Everything beyond that is still open. The leading candidates are all hypotheses.
- WIMPs (weakly interacting massive particles): heavy particles that would feel gravity and the weak nuclear force, but not light.
- Axions: extremely light particles first proposed to solve a different problem in particle physics.
- Sterile neutrinos: hypothetical cousins of the neutrino that interact even less.
- Primordial black holes: black holes formed in the very early universe. They might explain a part of the total, but probably not all of it.
Ordinary neutrinos are real and plentiful, but they are too light and too fast to clump the way dark matter does.
The search has gone on for years. Underground detectors filled with liquid xenon, such as LUX-ZEPLIN in South Dakota and XENONnT in Italy, wait for a dark matter particle to bump into an atom.
Particle colliders such as the Large Hadron Collider look for it too. So far none of them has found a confirmed signal.
There is one serious alternative. In 1983 the physicist Mordehai Milgrom proposed MOND, modified Newtonian dynamics, which changes the law of gravity at very low accelerations instead of adding unseen mass.
MOND does well at fitting many galaxy rotation curves. It has a harder time with galaxy clusters and with the microwave background, which is why most cosmologists still favour dark matter.
Where it shows up in fiction
Dark matter is a gift to storytellers because it is real, large and unexplained. The most common move is to treat it as a hiding place: hidden mass, hidden worlds, hidden minds.
Blake Crouch's novel Dark Matter (2016) borrows the name for a thriller about a physicist who wakes up in a different version of his own life. The book is really about alternate realities, not about astrophysics.
Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy takes its title from Milton's Paradise Lost. In The Subtle Knife, though, the physicist Mary Malone studies dark matter in her Oxford lab, and the books weave that research into a story about particles that seem to think.
Other stories use dark matter as fuel, as a shield, or as the hiding place of a civilisation that shares our space but cannot touch us.
Writers often pair dark matter with other universes. That link is mostly fiction, but physicists do study speculative hidden sectors, groups of particles that would feel gravity but little else.
If you like cosmology turned into stories, our pieces on the multiverse and the Boltzmann brain follow the same path, from a physics puzzle to a fiction idea.
Common misconceptions
Dark matter is not a black hole
Black holes are made of ordinary matter, and we can see their effects. Some small primordial black holes are a possible candidate, but dark matter as a whole is mostly believed to be particles.
Dark matter is not dark energy
Dark matter pulls things together through gravity. Dark energy appears to push space apart faster and faster.
It is not antimatter or another universe
Antimatter is well understood and lights up when it meets matter. Dark matter is part of our universe, even if we do not know what it is.
It is called dark because it is invisible, not because it is sinister
A better name would be transparent matter, since it does not interact with light at all. The word dark just means we cannot see it.
We have not found it yet
We have found its gravitational effects many times over. We have not identified the particle or the cause, and a few researchers think gravity itself may need changing.
It may be passing through you right now
If dark matter is made of particles, trillions of them could cross your body every second without any effect. That is why detectors need to be shielded deep underground.
Read next
Multiverse: why physicists and novelists alike take the idea of other universes seriously, and where the physics ends and the fiction begins.
Boltzmann brain: another case of a cosmology thought experiment that became a favourite of science fiction.
History of science fiction: the bigger map of how the genre has used real science to ask strange questions.