0% • 7 min left

Book Review Text (Resensi): Structure and Sample

November 16, 2026
A resensi, or book review text, is a written review of a book with its details, an orientation, a synopsis, an evaluation of strengths and weaknesses, and a recommendation. This page gives a sample novel review, a fair way to judge a book, and three-level model answers.
Book Review Text (Resensi): Structure and Sample

Key facts

Text type
Resensi (book review text)
Curriculum
Kurikulum Merdeka, Bahasa Indonesia Fase E and F
Structure
Book details, orientation, synopsis, evaluation, recommendation
Purpose
Helps readers decide whether a book is worth reading
Language features
Evaluative words, connectors, opinions backed by reasons
Examples on this page
Laskar Pelangi (Andrea Hirata) and Negeri 5 Menara (Ahmad Fuadi)

A resensi in five minutes

A resensi, or book review text, is a written review of a book, whether a novel, a short-story collection or a non-fiction title. It combines a summary with the writer's judgement, so that readers can decide whether the book is worth their time.

Under Kurikulum Merdeka you meet this text in Bahasa Indonesia, Fase E and F, usually as a task to review a book you have read. Marks go to structure, accuracy, the reasons behind your judgement, and language use.

This page explains the structure, gives a sample novel review, and shows how to judge a book fairly. Model answers at three levels close the page so you can compare them with your own work.

All examples are for learning, not for copying. Teachers quickly notice a review that does not come from a book the student has really read.

Structure of a resensi

Textbooks list the parts in slightly different orders, but the frame is almost always the same. Use the five parts below and adjust to your class textbook.

1. Book details

This part gives the title, author, publisher, year of publication and number of pages. Copy them from the cover and the copyright page, not from memory, because a wrong publisher or year often costs marks.

2. Orientation

The orientation introduces the book and its author briefly. It can mention the author's background, the main theme, or why the book is worth discussing.

3. Synopsis or interpretation

Here you summarise the content in your own words. For a novel, name the main character, the setting and the central conflict without giving away the ending.

For non-fiction, summarise the main idea and how the author builds the argument. One or two paragraphs are enough, not a chapter-by-chapter retelling.

4. Evaluation: strengths and weaknesses

This part decides most of the mark. Every judgement needs a reason and an example from the book, such as “the plot is easy to follow because each chapter ends with a new question”, not just “the plot is good”.

Balance both sides. A review that only praises sounds like an advertisement, while one that only criticises sounds like a complaint.

5. Summary and recommendation

Close with your overall judgement and the readers who would enjoy the book, for example teenagers who like stories of friendship or readers who want to see history through a character's eyes.

Sample novel review

The sample below reviews the novel Laskar Pelangi by Andrea Hirata. It is deliberately short, to model the structure, not to be imitated sentence by sentence.

Book details. Title: Laskar Pelangi.

Author: Andrea Hirata. Publisher: Bentang Pustaka.

First published: 2005. Type: novel.

Orientation. Laskar Pelangi tells of a group of children in Belitung who study in a simple school building that is close to collapse.

Since its release in 2005 it has become one of the best-known Indonesian novels.

Synopsis. Ikal, the narrator, studies with his classmates at SD Muhammadiyah under their teacher Bu Muslimah.

Despite poverty they stay eager to learn, and Lintang's intelligence stands out among them.

Strengths. The characterisation is strong, since each child has a memorable personality, such as clever Lintang and art-loving Mahar.

The language is lively and humorous, so the theme of poverty never feels gloomy.

Weaknesses. Some scientific terms and long comparisons may trouble teenage readers.

The plot also moves between episodes, so the focus sometimes feels scattered.

Recommendation. The novel suits junior and senior high students who want to see the value of education and friendship.

Readers who like fast plots may need patience at the start.

Notice that each part uses one or two focused sentences. Judgements come with reasons, and the recommendation names the right readers.

Resensi, ulasan and synopsis: what is the difference?

A synopsis is only a summary of the content, while a resensi adds judgement and a recommendation. A review that merely retells the book is therefore incomplete.

The word ulasan is broader than resensi. An ulasan can discuss a book, film, product or performance, while a resensi is usually reserved for written works.

In school the two terms are often used interchangeably with a similar frame. Follow the term and format your teacher asks for.

As a sample opening for a review of Bumi Manusia by Pramoedya Ananta Toer: “This novel invites readers to see the colonial era through the eyes of a native student who keeps asking questions.”

An opening like this names the book's point of view straight away and makes readers curious.

Language of a resensi

A review blends facts about the book with the writer's opinion. Keep the two clearly apart so readers can tell data from judgement.

  • Evaluative words such as interesting, strong, weak and moving express judgement.
  • Contrast connectors such as however, but and although link strengths to weaknesses.
  • Cause connectors such as because and since support the reason for a judgement.
  • Adjectives and adverbs describe characters, plot and style.
  • Recommendations use phrases of advice, such as worth reading and best suited to.
  • Write book titles in italics or quotation marks, following your school's style guide.

How to judge a book fairly

Before writing the evaluation, choose criteria. With criteria, your judgement is not only a matter of taste.

  • Novels: theme, characters, plot, setting, point of view, style and message.
  • Non-fiction: accuracy of data, organisation, clarity of language and usefulness to readers.
  • Physical features: cover, layout, font size and illustrations, where relevant.

Build each judgement in three steps: state it, show the evidence from the book, then explain the effect on readers.

For example: the characters are strong (judgement) because each friend has a different background (evidence), so readers remember them and care about them (effect).

Remember that a review judges the book, not the author. Use polite wording such as “weak”, “needs work” or “could be better”, and avoid words that belittle.

From weak to strong: one evaluation

Notice how one judgement can move up a level. The three examples below discuss the characters of the same novel.

  • Weak: “The characters are good.” This gives no reason at all.
  • Fair: “The characters are good because they have different personalities.” There is a reason, but it is still general.
  • Strong: “The characterisation is strong because each friend has a different origin and ambition, so their conversations feel alive and readers care about each fate.” This has a reason, evidence and an effect.

Reviewing non-fiction

The principle is the same, but the synopsis and criteria differ. In non-fiction, the synopsis summarises the main ideas and the author's argument rather than a plot.

The evaluation asks whether the data are accurate, whether sources are reliable and whether the chapters follow a clear order. A review of a history book, for instance, should judge factual accuracy and balance of viewpoint, not just enjoy the topic.

The recommendation is adapted too, for example to students preparing a history assignment or general readers who want a light introduction.

Writing a resensi from scratch

  1. Read the whole book, marking characters, conflicts and memorable passages.
  2. Note the book details from the cover and copyright page.
  3. Write a synopsis of three to five sentences in your own words.
  4. Choose two strengths and one or two weaknesses, then find evidence for each.
  5. Shape the orientation and recommendation so they connect with your evaluation.
  6. Check spelling, punctuation and whether every judgement has a reason.

Common mistakes

  • Retelling the plot without any judgement.
  • Praising or criticising without reasons and examples from the book.
  • Revealing the ending in the synopsis.
  • Mixing facts and opinions so readers cannot tell them apart.
  • Copying a review from the internet, which is easy to spot and builds no skill.
  • Getting the book details wrong, especially author, publisher and year.

What teachers usually mark

Rubrics vary by school, but these five areas almost always appear.

  • Completeness of structure: details, orientation, synopsis, evaluation and recommendation.
  • Accuracy: names, setting and events match the book.
  • Depth of evaluation: a reason and an example for every judgement.
  • Language: evaluative words, connectors, spelling and effective sentences.
  • Originality: the text shows you really read the book.

How to use the model answers

Read the question and write your own review first, without looking at the samples. Then compare it with the basic, good and excellent levels and note what your text lacks.

The teacher notes explain why each answer earns its level and what to add. Treat them as a checklist, not as an answer to copy.

Exam practice: sample answers

Model answers are examples to learn from; write your own in your words.

resensi

1. Write a novel review (about 150–250 words) of a young-adult novel you have read. It must include book details, an orientation, a synopsis, an evaluation (strengths and weaknesses) and a recommendation.

Outline

  1. Note the book details from the cover and copyright page.
  2. Write a one- or two-sentence orientation about the author or theme.
  3. Write a synopsis without giving away the ending.
  4. Choose strengths and weaknesses and give reasons and examples from the book.
  5. Close with a recommendation for suitable readers.
Basic Model answer

Book details. Title: Negeri 5 Menara.

Author: Ahmad Fuadi. Publisher: Gramedia Pustaka Utama.

Year: 2009. Type: novel.

Orientation. This novel is about students in an Islamic boarding school.

It is the first book in a trilogy.

Synopsis. Alif is a boy from Maninjau who wanted to go to a regular high school, but his parents send him to a boarding school in East Java.

There he meets five friends and learns that hard work pays off.

Strengths. The story is interesting and easy to follow.

It teaches readers about friendship and hard work.

Weaknesses. Some parts feel slow, and some Arabic words are not explained.

Recommendation. I recommend this novel to students who want motivation.

Overall, it is worth reading.

Why this level: The structure is complete and the facts are right, but the evaluation is general (“interesting”, “teaches readers”) with no reasons or examples. To reach good, explain why each judgement is made and point to evidence from the book.
Good Model answer

Book details. Title: Negeri 5 Menara.

Author: Ahmad Fuadi. Publisher: Gramedia Pustaka Utama.

Year: 2009. Type: inspirational novel.

Orientation. Negeri 5 Menara is the first book of a trilogy by Ahmad Fuadi, who studied at an Islamic boarding school himself.

It deals with education and friendship, two themes close to a student's life.

Synopsis. Alif Fikri, a teenager from Maninjau, wanted to attend senior high school but follows his mother's wish to study at Pondok Madani in East Java.

There he befriends five other students from different regions, and the six become known as Sahibul Menara.

Through lessons, punishments and shared dreams, Alif learns that effort and prayer must go together.

Strengths. First, the characters are strong because the six friends differ in origin and temperament.

Second, the language is light and humorous, so themes of discipline never feel preachy. Third, the book gives a realistic picture of boarding-school life.

Weaknesses. However, several Arabic and English terms appear without enough explanation, so beginners may need a dictionary.

Some chapters also repeat the same lesson about perseverance.

Message. The novel teaches that big dreams need serious effort and the support of friends.

The message works because it comes through the characters' experiences rather than direct advice.

Recommendation. Overall, it suits junior and senior high students who need encouragement to study.

Teachers can also use it to discuss ambition and friendship. Its strengths outweigh its weaknesses, so it is a sound choice.

Why this level: Each judgement now has a reason and some have an example, and a message section is added. What is still missing is use of the author's background, a comparison with another book, and a sharper weighing of how serious the weaknesses are. Excellent adds these.
Excellent Model answer

Book details. Title: Negeri 5 Menara.

Author: Ahmad Fuadi. Publisher: Gramedia Pustaka Utama.

Year: 2009. Type: inspirational novel, first of a trilogy.

Orientation. Among Indonesian young-adult novels, Negeri 5 Menara stands out because it makes the boarding school its main setting without turning the story into a sermon.

Ahmad Fuadi draws on his own years in such a school, and the everyday detail feels convincing.

Synopsis. Alif Fikri, from Maninjau, wanted senior high school but obeys his mother and enrols at Pondok Madani in East Java.

There he becomes close to five classmates from other regions, the group called Sahibul Menara.

The central conflict is not an outside enemy but Alif's inner struggle between his own wishes and his parents' hopes.

Strengths. Characterisation is the novel's greatest strength.

The six friends differ in origin, habits and ambition, so their friendship shows a meeting of many cultures, and it grows through study, punishment and conversation rather than through the author's explanation.

The repeated motto “man jadda wajada”, roughly “whoever strives will succeed”, guides the characters but never becomes a slogan, because failure and homesickness keep testing it.

Weaknesses. On the other hand, Arabic and English terms often appear with too little explanation, so readers unfamiliar with boarding-school life must stop to look them up.

Several chapters also stress perseverance in a similar pattern, which lowers tension in the middle.

These flaws do not ruin the novel, but they reduce comfort for readers who like fast plots.

Message and comparison. The main message is that great ambitions need effort and friends.

It persuades because Alif is not perfect: he doubts, misses home and wants to quit, so determination looks like a skill that is practised, not an inborn trait.

Compared with Laskar Pelangi, which follows children in a poor school on Belitung, this novel focuses on perseverance in a boarding school; Laskar Pelangi is more playful and poetic, while Negeri 5 Menara is more disciplined and purposeful.

Recommendation. Overall, Negeri 5 Menara suits junior and senior high students who are unsure about their path, and teachers can use it to discuss perseverance and friendship.

Readers who want to follow the characters can continue with the next two books.

Since its strengths outweigh its weaknesses, it deserves a place on a personal reading list, not only on a school assignment.

Why this level: This review has a clear point of view, evidence for each judgement, a comparison with another novel, an interpretation of the message and a recommendation fitted to readers. The criticism is polite but firm. High marks come from precise reasons and balance, not from length.

Marking rubric

  • Complete structure: details, orientation, synopsis, evaluation, recommendation.
  • Content matches the book and the synopsis does not reveal the ending.
  • Every judgement has a reason and an example from the book.
  • Strengths and weaknesses are balanced and politely worded.
  • Language is accurate: evaluative words, connectors, spelling, effective sentences.

Now write your own

Choose a novel you have really read and write your own review with the same frame. Then compare it with the three levels above and note one thing you can improve.

argumentative essay

2. A friend says a resensi can simply praise the book, because criticism may offend the teacher or the author. Write a short argumentative essay responding to this view.

Outline

  1. State your position in one clear thesis.
  2. Give two or three reasons, each with an example.
  3. Answer a likely objection.
  4. Close with a conclusion that confirms the thesis.
Basic Model answer

I disagree with this opinion. A review that only praises does not help readers.

First, a review helps people decide whether a book suits them. If every book is praised, readers cannot tell good books from weak ones.

Second, every book has weaknesses. For example, a novel may have a good story but difficult language.

Third, teachers mark the reasons in a review, not just praise or criticism. So students may write about weaknesses if they are polite.

If someone writes “very good” without a reason, readers do not know which part is good. A writer should mention the characters, plot or language.

So a review should include both strengths and weaknesses. This gives readers an honest picture before they read.

Why this level: The position is clear and the reasons are sensible, but the points are general, the example is hypothetical and no objection is answered. It reads as a list rather than an essay. To reach good, write a firm thesis, develop each reason with an example and answer one objection.
Good Model answer

The idea that a review can simply praise sounds safe, but it defeats the purpose of a review. I argue that a good review must include strengths and weaknesses, each with a clear reason.

First, consider function. A review helps readers decide whether a book is worth reading, and they can only decide if the picture is honest.

Without criticism, a review turns into promotion.

For example, a review that only says “the story is interesting” gives no information. A review that explains that the plot grows slowly but the ending feels rushed gives readers something real to weigh.

The same applies to non-fiction: a review of a history book should judge whether its data are accurate and its chapters well ordered, not only praise the topic.

Second, consider trust. Readers distrust praise without limits because it sounds like advertising, while a balanced judgement shows that the writer really read the book.

Some worry that criticism is impolite to the author. This can be solved by using respectful language and criticising the book's content, not the author as a person.

Third, consider learning. Writing about weaknesses trains students to judge a book against criteria such as theme, characters, plot and language, and to give reasons.

This skill helps in essays and discussions.

In conclusion, a good review does not stop at praise. It names strengths and weaknesses, supports both with examples, and ends with a recommendation for the right readers.

Why this level: There is a firm thesis, three developed reasons, examples and an answer to an objection. What is missing: an example from a real book, the distinction between reasoned and empty criticism, and linking phrases that make the argument one whole. Excellent adds these.
Excellent Model answer

The view that a review can simply praise, to avoid offending teachers or authors, looks safe but fails in two ways. It turns the review into advertising, and it teaches students that judging means pleasing people rather than giving reasons.

First, consider function. Readers open a review to decide whether a book is worth reading, and that decision needs contrast: what is strong, what is weak, and who the book suits.

Compare two sentences about one novel. “This novel is very good” cannot be checked, whereas “the characters are strong because each friend has a different origin, but foreign terms are poorly explained” can be tested by other readers.

The second sentence both praises and criticises, and that is exactly why it is trusted.

Second, consider the opposing view. Some say criticism is rude to an author who worked hard.

The worry deserves respect, but it confuses criticising a work with attacking a person.

A review judges the text, not the writer. With polite language and specific reasons, criticism of a rushed plot or unexplained terms actually honours the book by treating it as worth reading seriously.

Third, consider structure and learning. The evaluation section exists for strengths and weaknesses, so a review without weaknesses omits a required part.

Students who only praise also miss practice in using criteria such as theme, characters, plot and language.

Still, unreasoned criticism is as poor as empty praise. “The book is boring” is no more useful than “the book is amazing”, because both only state taste.

A concrete case shows the balance. A review of Laskar Pelangi may rightly praise its lively characters, yet also note that some scientific terms and long comparisons can burden teenage readers.

The two notes complete each other: readers learn what they will enjoy and what to prepare for.

How can criticism be both safe and honest? Start from an observation in the book, state its effect on readers, then offer a suggestion.

For example: unexplained Arabic terms send beginners to a dictionary, so footnotes would help.

This habit also matters beyond the Indonesian classroom. In an age of online reviews, students constantly meet unexplained five-star ratings and unfair complaints, so separating reasoned opinion from mere taste is real literacy.

In short, what makes a review good is not a positive or negative tone but balance and evidence. A writer who names strengths, weaknesses and a recommendation with examples from the book is doing the job owed to readers.

Why this level: The thesis is sharp, the reasons are layered, the opposing view is answered fairly, the writer admits that empty criticism is just as weak, and a real book anchors the example. The conclusion returns to the thesis. The level comes from control and precision, not from length.

Marking rubric

  • Clear thesis kept throughout.
  • Reasons supported by relevant examples, including one from a real book.
  • Opposing view answered fairly.
  • Logical structure: opening, body, conclusion.
  • Polite, accurate and effective language.

Now write your own

Write your own argumentative essay (about 300 words) with a thesis you believe in, then check that every reason has an example and that you have answered one objection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the structure of a resensi?

A resensi has book details, an orientation, a synopsis or interpretation, an evaluation of strengths and weaknesses, and a summary with a recommendation. Textbooks may name or order the parts slightly differently, so match your class textbook. What must never be missing is a judgement with reasons.

What is the difference between a resensi and an ulasan?

Ulasan is the broader term, since it can cover books, films, products or performances, while resensi usually refers to books. In school both often share the same frame: introduction, summary, judgement and recommendation. Follow the term your teacher uses, because the difference is not always sharp in school tasks.

How do I write a good sample review of a novel?

Read the novel to the end, note the book details, then write a synopsis without giving away the ending. Pick criteria such as characters, plot and language, and judge each with a reason and an example from the book. Close with a recommendation for suitable readers, then check spelling and sentences.

May a review include a book's weaknesses?

Yes, and it should. The evaluation part exists for strengths and weaknesses, and a review that only praises sounds like an advertisement. State weaknesses politely, judge the book rather than the author, and add reasons and examples so readers can trust you. This gives readers an honest picture.

How long should a resensi be?

Length follows your teacher's instruction, so check the word or page limit in the task. If the limit is short, shorten the synopsis and keep the evaluation, because that part decides most of the mark. If the limit is generous, add an example from the book for each judgement. Start from that limit before writing.

How does a non-fiction review differ from a novel review?

For a novel, the synopsis covers characters, setting and conflict, and the evaluation judges characterisation, plot and style. For non-fiction, the synopsis summarises ideas and argument, and the evaluation judges accuracy of data, organisation and clarity. The frame stays the same, so choose criteria that fit the kind of book.

Check Your Understanding

Pick an answer for each question to see if you were right.

  1. Which part of a resensi contains the strengths and weaknesses of the book?

  2. What is the main difference between a resensi and a synopsis?

  3. Which evaluation sentence is strongest?

  4. Which connector suits linking a strength to a weakness?

  5. What should you avoid in the synopsis of a novel review?

Share:

About the Writer

Alex Ng
Alex Ng

Software Engineer & Writer

Software engineer with a passion for distilling complex ideas into actionable insights. Writes about finance, investment, entrepreneurship, and technology.

Read more →

Keep reading

Explore the topic: Sastra SMA (Indonesia)

Articles

Summaries