Up next
Author
Tags
Share article
The post has been shared by 0 people.
Facebook 0
Twitter 0
Pinterest 0
Mail 0

The Behavior Gap Summary: Carl Richards’ Guide to Better Financial Decisions in 5 Minutes

Behavior Gap - Closing the Gap Between Investment Returns and Investor Returns

Carl Richards’ insights into closing the behavior gap that separates investment returns from investor returns.

Table of Contents

Introduction

Why do most investors earn significantly less than the mutual funds they invest in? Carl Richards’ ‘The Behavior Gap’ explores this puzzling phenomenon where investment returns are strong, but investor returns are weak—a difference caused entirely by human behavior. Richards, a certified financial planner and New York Times columnist, uses his famous simple sketches and clear explanations to illustrate how emotions, cognitive biases, and poor timing decisions destroy wealth over time. Published in 2012, this book doesn’t focus on picking better investments or market timing strategies—instead, it addresses the psychological barriers that prevent people from achieving their financial goals. Through real-world examples and practical solutions, Richards shows how to close the ‘behavior gap’ between what we should do financially and what we actually do. This 5-minute summary reveals the common behavioral mistakes that sabotage financial success and provides simple strategies for making better money decisions.

Book Overview

‘The Behavior Gap: Simple Ways to Stop Doing Dumb Things with Money’ tackles the disconnect between financial knowledge and financial behavior. Richards argues that most people already know what they should do with money—spend less than they earn, invest for the long term, diversify their portfolios—but consistently fail to follow through on this knowledge. The book explores why smart people make poor financial decisions and provides practical strategies for aligning behavior with intentions.

Richards structures the book around common behavioral pitfalls: buying high and selling low, chasing performance, overthinking simple decisions, and letting emotions drive financial choices. Rather than presenting complex investment strategies, he focuses on simple behavioral changes that can dramatically improve financial outcomes. His approach is compassionate rather than judgmental, recognizing that poor financial behavior often stems from normal human psychology rather than character flaws. The book targets anyone who has struggled to stick with financial plans or found themselves making money decisions they later regretted, offering hope that better behavior—not better market predictions—is the key to financial success.

Key Takeaways

  • The Behavior Gap is Real: The difference between investment returns and investor returns—caused by poor timing decisions—can cost individuals hundreds of thousands of dollars over their lifetime.
  • Emotions Drive Poor Decisions: Fear and greed cause investors to buy high during market peaks and sell low during market bottoms, destroying long-term wealth.
  • Simple Beats Complex: Complex financial strategies often lead to more mistakes. Simple, automated approaches typically produce better results.
  • Focus on What You Can Control: You can’t control market returns, but you can control your savings rate, asset allocation, and behavior during market volatility.
  • Automate Good Behavior: Setting up automatic savings and investment systems removes emotion from financial decisions and ensures consistency.
  • Values-Based Planning Works: Aligning financial decisions with your deepest values makes it easier to stick with long-term plans during difficult periods.
  • Mistakes are Expensive: Small behavioral mistakes compound over time into large opportunity costs that can significantly impact your financial future.

Core Concepts Explained

1. Understanding the Behavior Gap

Richards opens with the startling statistic that the average mutual fund earned 8.4% annually over a 20-year period, while the average mutual fund investor earned only 4.3% annually during the same time. This 4.1% difference—the behavior gap—represents the cost of poor timing decisions driven by emotions and psychological biases.

The behavior gap occurs when investors:

  • Buy High: Investing more money when markets are rising and optimism is high, often near market peaks when valuations are expensive
  • Sell Low: Withdrawing money when markets are falling and fear dominates, typically near market bottoms when opportunities are best
  • Chase Performance: Switching to last year’s winning investments just as their performance begins to lag
  • Panic During Downturns: Making emotional decisions during market volatility rather than sticking with long-term plans

Richards demonstrates that this gap exists across all types of investors and time periods, suggesting it’s a fundamental human behavioral challenge rather than a lack of market knowledge or investment skill.

Behavior Gap Concept - Investment Returns vs Investor Returns

The behavior gap represents the cost of poor timing decisions driven by emotion rather than logic.

2. The Role of Emotions in Financial Decisions

Richards explores how normal human emotions systematically lead to poor financial choices. He identifies key emotional patterns that destroy wealth:

Fear and Greed Cycles: During bull markets, greed and overconfidence lead to increased risk-taking and speculation. During bear markets, fear and panic lead to selling at the worst possible times. These emotions are strongest precisely when they’re most dangerous for financial decision-making.

Recency Bias: People extrapolate recent trends indefinitely, assuming bull markets will continue forever or that bear markets will never end. This bias causes investors to make major allocation changes based on short-term performance rather than long-term fundamentals.

Loss Aversion: Losses feel approximately twice as painful as equivalent gains feel good. This asymmetry causes investors to take excessive risk to avoid losses and to sell winning investments too early while holding losing investments too long.

Overconfidence: Success in one area (career, other investments) often leads to overconfidence in areas where expertise doesn’t transfer. This can result in excessive trading, concentration, or speculation that destroys wealth.

Richards emphasizes that these emotional responses are normal and predictable, not character flaws. Understanding these patterns is the first step toward making better financial decisions.

3. Simple Solutions for Complex Problems

Rather than fighting human nature, Richards advocates for simple systems that work with behavioral tendencies rather than against them:

Automate Everything: Set up automatic transfers for savings, investments, and bill payments to remove emotions from routine financial decisions. When good behavior is automatic, you don’t have to rely on willpower or market timing.

Dollar-Cost Averaging: Invest the same amount at regular intervals regardless of market conditions. This naturally buys more shares when prices are low and fewer when prices are high, smoothing volatility and preventing emotional timing mistakes.

Simple Asset Allocation: Use broad, diversified index funds rather than trying to pick individual stocks or time markets. Complexity often leads to more mistakes and higher costs without better returns.

Rebalancing Rules: Set specific rules for when and how to rebalance your portfolio (e.g., annually or when allocations drift more than 5% from targets). This forces you to sell high and buy low systematically rather than emotionally.

Time-Based Reviews: Review your portfolio and financial plan at predetermined intervals (quarterly or annually) rather than daily or weekly. Frequent monitoring increases emotional decision-making and harmful trading activity.

4. Values-Based Financial Planning

Richards advocates for connecting financial decisions to your deepest values and life goals rather than abstract financial metrics. This approach makes it easier to maintain discipline during difficult periods:

Identify Your ‘Why’: Understand what you’re really trying to achieve with money—security, freedom, family support, charitable giving. Clear purpose makes short-term sacrifices easier to accept.

Align Actions with Values: Make financial decisions that reflect your priorities rather than trying to maximize every dollar. Sometimes the ‘optimal’ financial choice isn’t the right choice for your situation and values.

Focus on Trade-offs: Every financial decision involves trade-offs. Understanding what you’re giving up and what you’re gaining helps you make choices you can live with long-term.

Plan for Obstacles: Anticipate challenges and setbacks rather than assuming everything will go perfectly. Having contingency plans reduces panic when problems arise.

This values-based approach helps investors stay committed to their plans during market volatility because they remember why they’re investing in the first place.

Critical Analysis

‘The Behavior Gap’ succeeds brilliantly at identifying and explaining the psychological barriers that prevent most people from achieving their financial goals. Richards’ use of simple sketches and clear examples makes complex behavioral finance concepts accessible to ordinary investors. His compassionate approach acknowledges that poor financial behavior often stems from normal human psychology rather than ignorance or character flaws, which makes his advice more palatable and actionable.

However, some critics argue that the book’s focus on behavioral issues may oversimplify the complexity of financial planning and investment management. While behavior is undoubtedly crucial, other factors like fees, tax efficiency, and asset allocation also significantly impact long-term returns. The book might benefit from more discussion of how to balance behavioral considerations with technical optimization.

Additionally, some financial professionals note that while Richards’ simple solutions work well for most people, high-net-worth individuals or those with complex financial situations might need more sophisticated strategies than basic automation and index fund investing. The book’s emphasis on simplicity, while generally beneficial, might not address all readers’ needs adequately. Despite these limitations, the book’s core insights about the importance of behavioral discipline remain valuable for the vast majority of investors seeking to improve their financial outcomes.

Practical Application

To close your own behavior gap and improve financial decisions:

  1. Automate Your Savings: Set up automatic transfers from checking to savings and investment accounts immediately after each paycheck arrives.
  2. Use Dollar-Cost Averaging: Invest the same amount monthly regardless of market conditions to smooth volatility and prevent timing mistakes.
  3. Simplify Your Portfolio: Use broad index funds rather than trying to pick individual stocks or time markets. Complexity often leads to more mistakes.
  4. Set Rebalancing Rules: Decide in advance when you’ll rebalance (annually or when allocations drift beyond set limits) and stick to the schedule.
  5. Limit Portfolio Monitoring: Check your investments quarterly or annually rather than daily to reduce emotional decision-making.
  6. Connect Money to Values: Regularly remind yourself why you’re saving and investing to maintain motivation during difficult periods.
  7. Plan for Setbacks: Anticipate market downturns and personal challenges, having contingency plans ready rather than making panic decisions.
  8. Get Professional Help: Consider working with a fee-only financial advisor who can provide objective guidance during emotional periods.

Remember, closing the behavior gap is about consistency and discipline, not perfect market timing or investment selection.

Conclusion

‘The Behavior Gap’ provides crucial insights into why smart people often make poor financial decisions and offers practical solutions for aligning behavior with financial goals. Richards’ message is both sobering and encouraging: while human psychology works against good financial behavior, simple systems and awareness can help anyone improve their financial outcomes dramatically. His emphasis on automation, simplicity, and values-based planning provides a framework that most people can implement regardless of their investment knowledge or experience.

The book’s greatest contribution lies in showing that financial success depends more on behavioral discipline than on investment expertise or market predictions. By focusing on what you can control—your savings rate, asset allocation, and responses to market volatility—rather than what you can’t control, you can close the behavior gap and achieve your financial goals more effectively. For anyone who has struggled to stick with financial plans or found themselves making emotional money decisions, Richards’ approach offers both explanation and hope for better financial behavior in the future.

You May Also Like

The Psychology of Money Summary: Morgan Housel’s Timeless Lessons on Wealth, Greed, and Happiness in 5 Minutes

The Psychology of Money Summary: Morgan Housel’s Timeless Lessons on Wealth, Greed,…

The Total Money Makeover Summary: Dave Ramsey’s 7 Baby Steps in 5 Minutes

The Total Money Makeover Summary: Dave Ramsey’s 7 Baby Steps in 5…